Sentara's Rate Fight With Anthem Puts Care for Thousands of Low-Income and Senior Virginians at Risk

Steven Paiva
Steven Paiva
November 19, 2026

Tens of thousands of Hampton Roads residents on Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and Affordable Care Act plans could lose in-network access to their doctors early next year after Sentara Health ended contract talks with Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Virginia.

Sentara announced Oct. 5, in the middle of open enrollment, that it was ending negotiations over those plans after Anthem did not accept its terms by an Oct. 1 deadline. About 53,000 Medicaid members, 25,000 Medicare Advantage members and 18,000 individual-plan members stand to lose access, according to Virginia Business.

The dispute comes down to affordability Anthem says Sentara is seeking price increases of 30 percent over three years for employer and individual plans, or roughly 10 percent a year.

"In most cases, we don't see employers giving wage increases at 10% year over year, unfortunately," said Monica Schmude, president of Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Virginia.

Anthem also says Sentara's own 2027 individual-market filing with state regulators seeks an increase of about 22 percent, compared with about 12 percent for Anthem's plan.

For patients, the deadlines are close. Medicare Advantage and ACA exchange members go out of network Jan. 1, and Medicaid members on Jan. 28. Talks over Anthem's employer plans, covering about 270,000 members statewide, remain unresolved ahead of the contract's Dec. 31 expiration. In all, about 215,000 Anthem members in Hampton Roads could face higher costs, News 3 WTKR reported.

Switching hospitals is not simple in Hampton Roads. Sentara operates 12 hospitals, employs more than 34,700 people and reports $14.2 billion in operating revenue, according to the company.

Sentara controls just over 72 percent of the region's inpatient market, according to a 2021 white paper commissioned by competitor Chesapeake Regional Medical Center. A 2023 state review found that Sentara and Riverside Health System together account for 80 percent of acute hospital patient days in Eastern Virginia.

The playbook is familiar. In 2021, Sentara notified Anthem it would end its Medicaid and Medicare contracts before rescinding the notice, and Anthem asked the attorney general to investigate "anti-competitive harm." "We do not think Medicaid and Medicare beneficiaries should be used as pawns by hospitals in contract negotiations," an Anthem official said then.

Sentara is also Anthem's competitor. It owns Sentara Health Plans, formerly Optima Health, with nearly 1 million members. After absorbing Virginia Premier, the plan became the state's largest Medicaid carrier, with 34 percent of enrollment as of July 2023.

That puts Sentara on both sides of the table. A state analysis found Sentara's own plan paid Sentara hospitals an average of $629 for a mid-level emergency visit in the Norfolk area, while other insurers paid Sentara $1,159. Anthem says Sentara's plan could cost its members more.

Sentara's Medicaid plan also lags on quality. Sentara Health Plans earned 3 out of 5 stars in the National Committee for Quality Assurance's 2026 ratings, the lowest among rated Virginia Medicaid plans. Anthem's HealthKeepers and UnitedHealthcare each earned 4 stars, and Aetna earned 3.5.

Medicaid members who switch plans to keep their Sentara doctors could end up in the state's lowest-rated option.

Patients have weeks to decide. Medicare open enrollment closes Dec. 7, and the ACA window closes Jan. 15.

Anthem says it still wants a deal. "We want Sentara to remain in our network, and I want to make that very, very clear," Schmude said.

Until one is reached, patients who depend on the region's dominant health system are left to wonder whether their next plan will keep their doctors.

Steven Paiva

Steven Paiva

Steven Paiva is a communications professional located in New England.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the newsletter everyone in Florida is reading.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Texas Politics
Cactus Politics
The Floridian
Dome Politics
Big Energy News