It is safe to say that most Americans (if not all) despise those pesky speed-detection cameras, or traffic safety cameras, and Flock or automatic license plate reading ( ALPR) cameras that municipalities install to hit speeders with traffic citations and use to collect vehicle data, respectively.
There is a big difference between the two types of cameras, and in New York State, during a November 9 joint committee public hearing in the state assembly, ALPRs were scrutinized.
Assembly member Nily Rozic drew a clear line: the hearing was about systems that can log virtually every passing vehicle, not the red-light and speed cameras that activate only when a violation occurs. The distinction matters as Albany weighs the state's first standards for plate readers, and as the two technologies are often confused.
What happened
In her opening remarks, Chair Rozic told colleagues the hearing was focused on ALPRs and not on traffic safety enforcement cameras, such as red light cameras or speed cameras, which she said serve a different and specific purpose and only activate when the violation occurs.
Lawmakers are weighing bills that would limit how plate reader data is used, shared and stored. Proposals discussed include generally requiring deletion within 48 hours. As you can imagine, protestors rallied against ALPR cameras outside the hearing room.
Interestingly enough, and according to NYPD, NYC DOT and the MTAthey there aren't any Flock Safety cameras in New York City.
The NYPD does have its own plate reading cameras but keeps the data internally and does not push that data out to national databases.
While speed cameras are a thorn in the side to drivers (no one likes getting those speeding notices in the mail), they have helped significantly reduce deadly speeding traffic accidents.
New York City ended 2025 with 205 traffic deaths, the fewest since record-keeping began in 1910. Speed cameras have reduced deadly speeding by more than 90%, and locations with newly installed cameras saw 14% fewer injuries and deaths than locations without them.
So, there is an arguement to be made on whether to keep speeding cameras, right?
As New York writes its first statewide rules for license plate readers, lawmakers are drawing the right line. Surveillance networks that track where drivers go raise real privacy questions. Traffic safety cameras that enforce red lights, school zone speed limits and bus lanes are a different technology with a different purpose, already governed by their own state laws. Keeping that lineclear lets Albany address surveillance without undercutting programs that make streets safer.
